I reviewed proposed prestressed concrete girder guidelines and drawings, the guidelines are concise and perfect, and covered all girder design issues, which is easy for design engineer to follow, and also the standard drawing are so much in details.
Read more
Thank you for the opportunity to provide comments. Please see attached MTO standard drawings and Girder Guidelines marked-up with our member's comments. Note that we only commented on the NU2400 unit drawing as the comments are applicable to all the other NU girder sizes as well.
Read more
This is a comment on the Prestressed Concrete Girder Guidelines (August11 2023).pdf document but more specifically on OPSS.PROV 909 clause 909.07.12.01.
Read more
NU girder depths documented in the guideline vary by different increments with a 300 mm difference between the 900 and 1200 girders and 400 mm difference between the 2000 and 2400 ones. Girder depths have been produced in the past that are different than the 7 sizes in the guidelines.
Read more
Prestessed Box Girders:
- On the standard grid arrangement on SS107-13, strands have been removed from the bottom corners of the cross-section and placed at the top of the cross-section, why have these been omitted from the corners?
Read more
View the comments this notice received through the registry. You can either download them all or search and sort below.
Some comments will not be posted online. Learn more about the comment status and our comment and privacy policies.
Download comments
Under 3.3 Hollow and Solid…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
378
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Under 3.3 Hollow and Solid Precast Slabs
The 1220 mm wide hollow slab typically contained three circular voids. However, they are not recommended for several reasons.
maybe use included in the standard OPSD? that will be more specific.
Read moreRelated actions
Page 12 Tightly spaced…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
379
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Page 12
Tightly spaced girders make it physically harder to properly view between the girders. The minimum spacing between NU girders should be 1.8 m.
The sentence in between the above seems not necessary.
Related actions
I reviewed proposed…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
380
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Related actions
Thank you for the…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
381
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Related actions
This is a comment on the…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
386
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Related actions
NU girder depths documented…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
387
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Related actions
Prestessed Box Girders: -…
Comment on
Prestressed Concrete Girders and Prestressed Concrete Girders Guidelines
Comment ID
388
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status
Related actions