Comment
1350.05.04.02 Plastic Concrete Requirements
- The specified concrete temperature limits are more restrictive than those in CSA A23.1 Table 14
Permissible concrete temperatures at placing - The reduced upper temperature limits (25 °C and 28 °C) do not account for the use of modern admixtures and mix designs that can maintain performance at higher temperatures.
- These prescriptive limits may result in unnecessary rejection of compliant concrete that meets CSA requirements for strength, durability, and workability.
- The requirement does not consider practical construction conditions, including ambient temperatures, haul times, and placement methods, which are addressed within CSA provisions.
- Imposing stricter temperature limits may increase project costs, scheduling challenges, and potential material waste without demonstrated performance benefit.
- As this is a design-build standard, CSA A23.1 should govern material and performance requirements, allowing flexibility in achieving compliance.
- It is recommended that temperature requirements align with CSA A23.1 and be based on performance criteria rather than fixed prescriptive limits.
Submitted March 24, 2026 5:03 PM
Comment on
NSP DB 1350 – Material Specification for Concrete – Materials and Production
TCP number
000-0288
Comment ID
554
Commenting on behalf of
Comment status